Connect with us

Fake News

A pregnant elephant’s death in Kerala got communalized



Kerala: A 15-year-old pregnant Elephant died in Palakkad district of Kerala on 27th May,  where multiple news agencies reported the incident as an elephant was fed cracker stuffed pineapple. This news has shaken us all and the social media was flooded with posts condemning the act and demanding the Kerala Police to book the culprit(s).

In the meantime, a few sections of social media started blaming Muslims for the death of the elephant, Tarek Fatah a Pakistani born Canadian, tweeted “The atrocity of feeding a pregnant elephant with pineapple full of firecrackers & killing her, took place in the Mallapuram district of India’s Kerala State. The district is the only Muslim-majority district of the state with an over 70% Muslim population. What are the chances?“. (Archive)

A twitter user @kaalicoffee wrote, “Getting to know that the pregnant elephant was killed in Kerala was in an area dominated by Muslims. The act was doe because Hindus consider elephant sacred…”.  She took down the tweet after it went viral.

Here is another tweet from the user after taking down the tweet.

Another user Madhur(@ThePlacardGuy) tweeted a video where he says “हाथी को भगवन मानते हो और फिर उन्ही भगवन को मार दिया, मल्लापुरम में ये घटना हुआ है, मैं चाहता हु की आप लोग Google पर जा कर मल्लापुरम का demographic चेक करो और खुद हे पता लगा लो की किसने मारा, अग्रर मैं बोल दूंगा की किसने मारा तोह आप लोग मुझे Islamophobic बोलने लगोगे ” (We believe that elephants are sacred and to be worshiped but on the other hand they were being killed. Please go to Google and search for demographics of Mallapuram, you will come to know who killed Elephant, if i tell you who killed it, you will start calling me Islamophobic.)

Archive link

Union minister Prakash Javadekar, Minister of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, tweeted that his government has taken a very serious note about the incident that happened in Mallapuram district of Kerala.  (Archive)

BJP MP from Sultanpur UP has also tweeted the “Mallapuram is know for its intense criminal activity especially with regards to animals. ” (archive)

Find more tweets here

It all begun with misleading news published by multiple agencies, which claimed that the incident happened in Malappuram district.

FactO Check:

Where did The Incident happen? 

The incident happened in the forest area of Palakkad District of Kerala, The forest area is on the border of Palakkad and Mallapuram district. CM Pinarayi Vijayan tweeted, “In a tragic incident in Palakkad dist, a pregnant elephant has lost its life. Many of you have reached out to us. We want to assure you that your concerns will not go in vain. Justice will prevail.”.

The NewsMinute editor-in-chief Dhanya Rajendran also tweeted that the incident had not taken place in Malappuram, but in Kottopadam panchayat in Mannarkad in Palakkad district.

How the Elephant Died?

As per the initial report and news agencies claim, the elephant died after eating cracker stuffed pineapple offered by someone.  According to Fact check published by IBT, it was learned that the reason for the elephant’s death was due to asphyxia where water had got into her lungs and trachea. Dr David Abraham, Assistant Forest Veterinary Officer, Thrissur, carried out the “preliminary postmortem” on May 28.

Even Kerala Forest Department has tweeted that, “There’s no conclusive evidence that injury to lower jaw was caused by pineapple stuffed wd cracker. However, this may be a possibility. Dept. has booked offence against unknown offenders, whose identity is being established.

As per an article published by The Quint, Mannarkkad District Forest Officer K Sunil Kumar clarified that there is no confirmation that the animal had consumed a pineapple, as dictated by media reports.

He said that the locals could not have fed a fruit stuffed with live firecrackers to a wild elephant inside the forest as that would be very dangerous.

“The animal had sustained injuries because of explosives in its mouth. This was an act done by some people living in the forest fringes to keep the animals away from his or her cultivated land. But this was not done intentionally to kill a pregnant elephant,” he told The Quint.

Many social media users have deliberately tried to give the incident a communal spin by claiming that the incident happened in Malappuram district, a Muslim majority district in Kerala. Multiple news agencies and fact-check websites have denied this claim.

ClaimReview: Pregnant Elephant killed in Mallapuram, a district known for violence again animals

Claim By: Menaka Gandhi, Prakash Javadekar

Fact Check by Facto News: MISLEADING

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fake News

Kangana Ranaut falsely claimed that Bilkis Bano (Shaheen Bagh Dadi) participated in farmers’ protest



Thousands of farmers from Haryana, Punjab, and Uttar Pradesh have been protesting since September against the three agriculture bills passed by the government. After failing to gain support from their respective state governments (except for Rajasthan and Punjab), the farmers’ union have decided to march to Delhi to mount pressure on the union government. The protesting farmers had a clash with the police near the interstate border at Haryana’s Ambala district where water cannons were used to disperse the protesters. Amidst this ongoing protests, a lot of BJP and right-wing supporters are trying to discredit the farmers’ protest by sharing misinformation across social media. A collage of images of two elderly woman iv viral across social media with a claim that Shaheen Bagh Dadi – Bilkis Bano was present at the farmers’ protest.

Bollywood actor Kangana Ranaut has quoted the viral tweet and made some degrading comments. She said the Dadi who featured in Time magazine for being the most powerful Indian is now available in 100rs. Kangana’s tweet has garnered thousands of likes before she took it down.

Twitter user Gaurav Pradhan tweeted the viral image and claimed that Shaheen Bagh Dadi was present at the farmers’ protest and is available for hire on a per daily basis, food, cloth and money. The tweet has garnered over a thousand retweets and thousands of likes.


FactO Check: 

The image on the left in the viral collage is the image of Bilkis Bano – Shaheen Bagh Dadi, published in several articles (here, here and here) during the Anti-CAA protests in Shaheen Bagh. Whereas the image on the right was posted by several Facebook pages and journalists during the farmers’ protests. According to Neel Kamal of Times of India, these elderly women are protesting against the farm-bills in Punjab.

Fact check website Boom has published a video where Bilkis Bano has refuted the viral claims. When Boom interview Bano at her house, she denied that the woman in the photo is not her. “I am sitting at home, in Shaheen Bagh. I am not the one in the photo. The farmers who are protesting and the photo of the woman that is being shared is not mine. I will be joining the protest tomorrow,” Bano told BOOM.

Conclusion: Bilkis Bano has clearly denied that she is not present at the farmers’ protests. It is evident that the elderly woman in the  yellow scarf is not Bilkis Bano -SHaheen Bagh Dadi as claimed by Kangana Ranaut and other social media users. The viral claim is false, misleading and an intentional attempt to malign the farmers’ protest.

Continue Reading

Fake News

Navika Kumar falsely claims that Congress has deleted Ahmed Patel’s pic from their website after his demise



Indian National Congress party veteran leader and Rajya Sabha MP Ahmed Patel passed away due to multiple organ failure on Wednesday. Ahmed Patel, the trusted aide to Sonia Gandhi was undergoing treatment for more than a month after he tested positive for Covid-19. The untimely demise of the veteran leader shook the party. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Sonia Gandhi and several other leaders have condoled Patel’s demise.  Navika Kumar’s (editor/journalist of Times Now) latest tweet about Ahmed Patel has created a stir in social media. Navika Kumar posted a picture supposedly taken from the Indian National Congress party’s website and claimed the party has now deleted the picture of Ahmed Patel from their website.

The picture is supposed of a computer monitor which displays the Indian National Congress party’s website and its treasurers. The viral tweet has garnered over 100 retweets before got deleted. The image was followed by some philosophical speech which roughly translates to, “We have come empty-handed and will leave empty-handed, the world quickly forgets”. Please see the tweet here

FactO Check:

When Navika Kumar posted the tweet, many users in the comment section proved her wrong by posting the screenshots of the INC’s website which still has Ahmed Patel’s picture as the treasurer. One can see the same in INC’s website here.

Facing a backlash for her untimely and immature tweet, Navika Kumar has deleted the post and tweeted an explanation that when she saw the website, she couldn’t find the pic.

Conclusion: Navika Kumar’s claim is fake, misleading, and utterly baseless. Sometimes photos on the website take a while to load. This is a very common problem and depends on the site loading speed too. There could be other reasons too. If only Navika Kumar have patiently waited to refresh the page or check it from other devices, she could have escaped this embarrassment. Even though the follow-up tweet was intended for damage recovery, the last line, “Pareshaan Kyun ho Bhai log?” destroys the sole purpose and clearly shows the lack of responsibility from a renowned journalist. Of course, people would be anxious Navika ji, you are a journalist, they expect you to report facts, not gossips.

Continue Reading

Fake News

Indian army denies media reports of ‘pinpoint strikes’ in PoK



Several media agencies today, citing a report by Press Trust of India (PTI) and govt. sources have published and broadcasted news claiming that the Indian army has carried out an airstrike in PoK (Pakistan Occupied Kashmir). Times of India citing govt. sources published an article, “India carries out ‘pinpoint strikes’ on terror launch pads in PoK: Govt sources” claiming that heavy damage was inflicted on terror camps in PoK. India Today, Times NowAmar Ujala, Dainik Bhaskar, and Dainik Jagran are some other agencies that have published similar reports.

Prominent journalists like Deepak Chaurasia, Anjana Om Kashyap, and Rubika Liyaquat have tweeted that Indian security forces have carried out targeted strikes in PoK and caused heavy damage to terror camps.

FactO Check: 

Press Trust of India on Thursday reported a story which stated, “The Indian Army is carrying out “pinpoint strikes” on suspected terror launchpads inside Pakistan-occupied Kashmir in response to Pakistani military’s unrelenting efforts to push a maximum number of terrorists into India before the onset of harsh winters, sources in the security establishment said on Thursday. The ‘deep state’ in Pakistan has tried to manage a fine balance between escaping the scrutiny by global anti-terror watchdog FATF and supporting terror at the same time with an aim to fuel unrest in Jammu and Kashmir, they said.”

Following the report by PTI and several other agencies, the Indian Army has clarified in a statement that no firing or ceasefire violation has happened on Thursday. The army also further clarified that, “The PTI story is based on analysis of the Ceasefire Violations (CFV) that took place on November 13. It is clarified that there has been NO firing or CFV in LC today”.  ANI has also tweeted the same stating that no firing has happened across the Line of Control today.

Conclusion: Based on the statement by the Indian Army, there has been no firing or airstrikes across PoK today. Whiles some of the journalists have clarified their mistakes, others just deleted their previous posts.

Continue Reading

Follow Facto on Facebook

Treading Tags