Connect with us

Religion

True! Muslim students were made to sit outside for board exams in Indore, MP

Published

on

Indore(MP): Class XII board exams were resumed on 9th June in Madhya Pradesh. A Bengali school located at Naulakha in Indore which was a center for the Class XII examination made headlines for discriminating against the students attending the examination on religious grounds.  National Herald, Mumbai Mirror, and many news agencies have reported this incident.

Class XII examinations in Madhya Pradesh, initially started on 2nd March was expected to be completed by 31st March. But due to the COVID-19 Lockdowns, the exams were deferred. As Unlock-1 relaxation started on 8th June, the board resumed the exams from 9th June.

Dainik Dopahar, a daily newspaper published an article, dated 10th June with a heading “मुस्लिम छात्रों को परीक्षा में स्कूल से बाहर बैठाया “, (Muslim students asked to sit outside the school during the exam).

A news portal by name clarionindia.net published an article on 10th June with heading “Indore: Muslim Students Taking Class 12 Exams Made to Sit Outside in Heat”.

FactO Check:

We have received requests from a lot of users to verify this news. We spoke to Dr. Aminul Khan Suri, the first to raise this matter to the school and district administration.  A Congress MLA, Arif Masood has also written to Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan expressing concern over the matter.

We spoke to Dr. Aminul Khan Suri and here is what he said, “Exams were started from 9th June and no students were seated separately. This started on 10th June on a Bengali school which was a center for 3 schools- Sita Devi, Asian, and Islamia Karimiya School(IK). The IK school girls were made to sit separately on 10th June. When asked about discrimination, the administration informed that SDM notified the Bengali school on 9th June that according to guidelines students from containment zone should be seated separately. On the Next day, Bengali School took the decision of making Islamiya karimiya School’s students sit separately for the exam. The school didn’t give these students any separate rooms and 47 girls from Islamiya karimiya School, who were appearing for the exam on the 10th were made to seat in a shed outside of the classroom in the summer heat”.

Circular passed for all Examination center:

The order says,  “This letter is in regards to the higher Secondary exam held in the district, we request you to kindly do not make students sit in the corridor, stage or sheds for their exams. This needs to be followed strictly. Orders by the collector of the district, Indore”.

FactO Editorial Opinion:

Generalizing students of Islamia Karimiya School, which has all Muslim students was not a good idea, the administration should’ve checked the addresses of students from the containment zone and asked them to sit in a separate room, but not in a shed.  A student from Asian and Sita Devi school could’ve also been from containment zone, but they were not checked and all students from Islamia school were asked to sit separately in a shed. Students should not feel discriminated because of their faith. We appreciate the decision of District Education officer, issuing orders to all exam centers to not make students sit in sheds or corridors.

Conclusion: This is true. Students were asked to sit outside the classroom just because of their Muslim identity. This shouldn’t have happened.

ClaimReview: Muslim students asked to sit outside the school during the exam

Claim By : Dopahar Samachar

Facto Check by Facto news: TRUE

Religion

8 year old video from Turkey viral as French police using water cannon to stop Muslims from praying

Published

on

By

France: France President Emmanuel Macron made derogatory remarks against Islam this month, which led to the Arab nations calling for a boycott of French products. Many Arab nations including, Morocco, Saudi Arab, Turkey, and Pakistan have condemned Macron’s comment on Islam. Amidst this controversy, a video is going viral where the police can be seen using water cannon over Muslim women protestors.

User (@YamrajFromHell) Parveen Chauhan, shared this video with the caption “Well done French police Streets are for the cars, not for praying.”,  (Archive)

Another user (@dharmicverangna) Vaidehi, shared the same video with a caption, “French police used water cannon to clear the streets of Yüksekova! Streets are for cars, not for praying.” Th user initially said that its from France and later clarified that the video is from Turkey and asked people to understand the joke.  (Archive)

Another user @PiyushTweets1 shared the video with the caption, “When India is going to come out with secularism band & when will we start similar practice in India”.

This video is shared by many other users without knowing the City name mentioned in the tweet “Yüksekova” is in Turkey but not in France. This video is viral on Facebook also.

FactO Check:

We did a reverse image search of some screenshots taken from the video and found a video posted on YouTube on 9thNOV 2012 with a caption in Turkish “Gaz bombalı ‘civil Cuma namazı – Yüksekova – Gever” (Civil Friday prayer with gas bombs – Yüksekova – Gever). According to another article published by yuksekovahaber.com.tr on 9th NOV 2012, citizens caught in the gas bombs performed their prayers without paying attention to the gas bombs. Citizens offering prayer reacted after the prayer and wanted to hold a sit-in action to support the hunger strikes. Police intervened with pressurized water and gas bombs against citizens who reacted and made a sit-in.

Youtube Video posted on 9th NOV 2012 from the same event.

Why this 8-year-old video is viral again?

The video was recently posted by @EdipBedirhan, with the same caption which is viral in India. The user has already clarified that the video is from Turkey and Turkish police, using water cannon against Kurdish protesters. User @EdipBedirhan wants to show the hypocrisy of Turkish President Erdogan who used water cannon against his own people.

Conclusion: An 8-year-old video posted by a Twitter user where water cannon and gas bombs were used against Muslims praying in Yüksekova,Turkey is being shared by Indian users with a different claim. The video is 8 years old and it’s from Turkey, not France.

 

Continue Reading

Religion

4 year old video of a Bangladesh teacher sexually harassing a student is viral as from Indian Madarsa

Published

on

A video of a teacher touching his student inappropriately is being shared by many social media users with a claim that the incident took place in a Madrasa (Islamic Pre-School). A Twitter user @gopugoswami shared the video from his account on October 19 with a claim, “बेटियों को मदरसा में भेजने से पहले विचार करें, उन्हें सरकारी विद्यालयों में भेज कर विज्ञान की शिक्षा दें, ये सब तो दुनियाँ सिखा ही देगी ( Think before sending daughters to madrasa, send them to government schools and teach science, all this will teach the world)”. The post has garnered over 3.5k retweets and more than 5k likes. 

A lot of social media users retweeted the video and appealed to ban Madrasas in India. Though the initial post by @gopugoswami never claimed where the incident happened, many users (here here here here) believed that it took place in India and demanded that all the Madrasas should be banned in India. A Twitter user @abhi14377 shared the video with a claim, “@AIMPLB_Official एक दिन तुम्हारे ये सारे मदरसे बंद होकर रहेंगे। छोटीबच्चियों पे अपनी भूख मिटाते हो धर्म की आड़ में कमिनो।(@AIMPLB_Official One day all these madrasas will be closed. Kaminos under the guise of religion to feed their hunger on small children. #Madarsa #JaiShriRam @myogiadityanath @SmritiIraniOffc @RubikaLiyaquat)” and tagged ‘All India Muslim Personal Law Board’, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath in his post. Some users replying to the post have called for the nationwide implementation of National Register of Citizens as in Assam and tagged Prime Minister Office and Home Minister Office with #BanMadarsa_SaveNation tags.

The same video was quoted by Shefali Vaidya with the caption, “Ugh, this was horrifying to look at.”. The video is viral over Facebook as well with almost the same caption. “बेटियों को मदरसा में भेजने से पहले विचार करें, उन्हें सरकारी विद्यालयों में भेज कर विज्ञान की शिक्षा दें, ये सब तो दुनियाँ सिखा ही देगी.” (Think before sending your daughters to Madarsa, Send them to a government school to give them education, this they can learn by time.)

FactO Check:

A reversed image search on Yandex(a Russian search engine) directed us to many YouTube videos which were uploaded on Bangladeshi channels. All these videos are recently uploaded though the original incident took place in July 2016.

As most of the videos on YouTube were in Bengali, we did some keyword searches and found multiple websites claiming that the video is almost 4 years old. A Bengali news website in their caption says “Old videos of teachers and students go viral again”, another website by the name tekdeeps.com claims the same. According to Tekdeep, the viral video is of Nurul Haque Sardar, the headmaster of Sonar Bangla Secondary School in Uzirpur upazila of Barisal. He opened a coaching center for female students in a rented room next to the school. This video of sexual harassment of the students who came to study at the coaching center was first spread in the area in June 2016 through the locals.

At the same time, after investigating the incident from the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Education stopped the salary and allowance of teachers from July of that year. He was also expelled from school at the same time.

Conclusion: Videos is neither from Madarsa nor from India. It’s a 4-year-old video from Bangladesh where the incident occurred in the Girl’s only Tuition center. The above claims are misleading.

 

 

Continue Reading

Religion

Killing of a woman from Madhya Pradesh is given communal angle, Accused Sohan is falsely identified as Rizwan

Published

on

By

Rajasthan: A Facebook user Ravindra Bharatiya posted a photo of a half-burnt women, claiming she was raped by ‘Rizwan Ansari’ in the Tonk district of Rajasthan. User wrote in Hindi “दिल दहलाने वाली यह तस्वीर राजस्थान के जिला #टोंक के #निवाई तहसील की है जहां १३ वर्षीया #पायल_जैन को उसी तहसील के #रिज़वान_अंसारी ने बलात्कार के बाद जिंदा जला दिया। राजस्थान सरकार और मीडिया चुप हैं, क्योंकि राजस्थान में फिलहाल चुनाव नहीं हैं। और भाड़े की सरकार तथा मीडिया के लिये जातीय समीकरण फिट नहीं बैठ रहा है। (This heart breaking photo is from Nivari tahsheel of Tonk district in Rajasthan, 23 year old Payal Jain was raped and burnt alive by Rizwan Ansari. Rajasthan government and Media is silent). (Archive)

The user has also made an appeal to his followers that not to give ‘angry reaction’, which will reduce his post reach. According to his Facebook profile, Ravindra Bhariya is from Lucknow of Uttar Pradesh.

Another user Ashok Kumar has posted the same photo, and wrote, “दिल दहलाने वाली यह तस्वीर राजस्थान के टोंक ज़िला निवाई तहसील की हैं,जहाँ १३ वर्षीय पायल को उसी तहसील के रिज़वान अन्सारी ने बलात्कार के बाद ज़िन्दा जला दिया। राजस्थान सरकार और मीडिया चुप हैं,क्यों?” (This hear breaking photo is from Nivari tahsheel of Tonk district in Rajasthan, 23-year-old Payal Jail was raped and burnt alive by Rizwan Ansari. Rajasthan government and Media is silent). (Archive)

FactO Check:

With Google reverse image search, we found few YouTube videos reporting the incident (here,& here). According to an article published in Nava Bharat, the body was first found on 29th SEP 2020. The viral photo is from the Gandhwani district of Madhya Pradesh, where the women’s friend wanted to get rid of her and got her killed, and burned the body with the help of his friend. According to the Police and charge sheet, accused Sohan has accepted the crime and the reason he told to the police was that he wanted to get rid of the women but she didn’t agree and Sohan was already married. So he planned her murder with his friend.

We also found a Zee News article, published on 4th October. the caption reads “wanted to get rid of women when she was not convinced, the man got her killed with help of a friend.”

According to a fact check published by Factly, there was no rape reported and the FIR filed on the incident does not mention rape. Only sections 302, 201 and 34 of IPC were mentioned. The FIR can be read here

Image: Factly

Conclusion: In our investigation, the claim is found to be false, misleading and Islamophobic. Social media users should refrain from posting fake posts that push a communal angle.

 

 

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Follow Facto on Facebook

Treading Tags

Trending