D.C. Circuit Examines Trump’s Takeover of Independent Agencies: FTC and SEC at Play
The DC Circuit heard arguments on Tuesday about the decision trump of independent agencies, and the FTC and the SEC They await the fine print.
The panel—Karen Henderson, Cornelia Pillard and Harry Edwards, appointed by Bush Sr., Obama and Carter—reviewed two files: the dismissal of the advisers of the United States Institute of Peacecreated by Congress to mediate conflicts, and the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Council, which oversees 9/11 anti-terrorism programs.
Both cases had been on hold for months, waiting for the Supreme Court resolve the extent of the president’s firing power over the executive branch. The answer came with 6-3 Trump v. Slaughterwhich endorsed the free dismissal in the majority of independent agencies, and with the 5-4 of Trump v. cookwhich shielded the Federal Reserve. With this framework, the files were reactivated this summer.
The lawyer of Department of Justice McKaye Neumeister supported his argument in Slaughter: ‘USIP’s activities are analogous to other exercises of the president’s foreign policy powers.’ And he concluded: ‘The legal restrictions on his removal are unconstitutional.’
William Murphy, a lawyer for those fired, argued the opposite: USIP is not an entity of the executive branch, but a creature of Congress designed to be independent. The judges did not fully buy either version. They asked how a research and mediation institute exercises executive power.
In the second case the wind blew differently. The panel was more receptive to the arguments of the White Houseand the debate revolved around a technical detail: the rule that created that council does not contain explicit protection against dismissal without cause. The judges did not announce when they will rule.
Who controls the firing controls the agenda: that is exactly what is being settled in the DC Circuit
Why the FTC and SEC are in the room even though no one named them
What the DC Circuit sets is not limited to two obscure pieces of advice: it reaches all independent commissions. The foundation stone of that building is, precisely, an FTC case. In 1935, the Supreme Court ruled Humphrey’s Executor against Franklin D. Roosevelt: the president had fired a commissioner of the FTC and the court said he couldn’t. For ninety years, that ruling was the shield of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the FCC, and the NLRB.
Slaughter shattered that shield for almost all of them. Cook left the Federal Reserve in a glass case, for its unique role in monetary policy. In practice, commissioners serve today at the will of the tenant of the White House. What the Circuit must decide now is the plumbing: what counts as ‘executive power’ and whether the legal protections are separable from the rest of the law.
It is not an abstract debate. The Federal Trade Commission reviews mergers, pursues anticompetitive practices and monitors advertising. The SEC writes the accounting and disclosure rules used by all New York-listed companies. A change of majority in these commissions is a change of doctrine with immediate effect on the price of capital.
Washington Logic
From within the system, the question that remains is not whether trump wants to control regulators. It is who answers to the voter when a commissioner appointed by a previous president blocks the agenda that voter voted for. The theory of the unitary executive—all executive power rests with the president, not in semi-autonomous commissions—has been under construction for half a century in the Federalist Society. Slaughter is his biggest victory.
The precedent is old. Myers v. United States (1926) already maintained that the president can remove executive officials without permission from Congress; Humphrey’s Executor he corrected it in 1935 and Seila Law (2020) narrowed the circle again. He Republican Party It has been preparing this closure for a decade; The Democratic Party reads it in terms of concentration of power.
For Spain, institutional noise translates into regulatory risk premium. SantanderBBVA, Telefónica and Iberdrola list or issue debt in the United States and file accounts with the SEC: Every accounting or disclosure change costs them real money. The operations of Spanish groups with an American presence—Ferrovial, Acciona, ACS—go through the review of the FTC, which resolves in months what a court would take years to do.
The difference with other partners is one of exposure, not opinion. Germany has its automobile in the tariff crosshairs; Spain has more capital listed in New York and more regulated business in Washington than its size suggests. The Government has not established a position on this lawsuit, and it does not have to: it is an internal American matter. But it is convenient that Madrid follow the view as a tariff follows.
The panel did not announce when it will rule. The reasonable thing is that it does so throughout 2027 and that its decision returns to the Supreme Court, which in December hears an immigration case on deportations to third countries. High court record is mixed: Won on Slaughter, lost on tariffs and birthright citizenship. Nothing guarantees that the next one will fall on the side of the White House.
Case File
- The case: The DC Circuit, the federal appeals court in Washington, is reviewing whether Trump can fire the advisers of two agencies created by law at will.
- Key facts: The Supreme Court endorsed free dismissal in Trump v. Slaughter (6-3) and shielded the Federal Reserve in Trump v. Cook (5-4). The doctrine reaches the FTC and the SEC.
- For Spain: Santander, BBVA, Iberdrola and Telefónica present accounts before the SEC; Their mergers in the US go through the FTC.
