The House of Representatives buries Hegseth’s impeachment and Democrats will retry it in January
IN 30 SECONDS
- What has happened? The House of Representatives has voted 211-204 to refer the eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, signed by Republican Thomas Massie.
- Who is behind? Massie, the only Republican who voted with the Democrats; a leadership of the Republican Party that shields the secretary; and Donald Trump, who talks about ‘exoneration’.
- What impact does it have? Hegseth continues to lead the Pentagon in the middle of the war with Iran and the fight moves to Congress that takes office in January, with effects on Rota and Morón.
This Tuesday, the House of Representatives buried the impeachment resolution against Pete Hegseth by 211 votes to 204.
Massie had registered the eight articles on Monday night and forced the House to speak. The charges were sent to the judicial committee, a procedure that in practice is equivalent to a burial: that committee is controlled by the Republican majority and does not plan to process them in the remainder of the legislature. The calendar rules more than the arguments.
Eight charges, a 1973 law and a regulation that outweighs the evidence
Hegseth appeared that same morning, hours before the vote, to describe the attempt as a ‘farce’ and ‘political spectacle’ motivated by Massie’s ‘ego and resentment’. His thesis: what lies behind are not serious crimes and serious misdemeanors – the formula that the Constitution reserves to the impeachmentthe impeachment process of high federal officials—but policy discrepancies. ‘Secretary Hegseth is not going to back down or allow himself to be intimidated by politicians who seek partisan points or launch false investigations where there is no irregularity,’ concluded Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell.
The article is anything but routine. He accuses the Secretary of Defense of waging a war in violation of the War Powers Act of 1973 – the rule that requires the president to report to Congress in 48 hours and withdraw troops in 60 days if there is no express authorization -, of ordering extrajudicial executions, of suppressing freedom of expression, of ignoring laws that minimize civilian casualties, of the kidnapping of former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and of conducting an ‘illegal war’ in Yemen.
The arithmetic is what could be expected in a House where the Republicans still have a majority. Massie was the only Republican who voted with the Democrats and seven party colleagues didn’t even bother to show up. 211 votes to archive, 204 to move forward. The detail is recorded in the legislative file of Congress.
Referring an impeachment to a commission is the cleanest way Washington has to kill a case without actually voting on it.
Nobody moved from the spot.
Who missed the vote and why the Democratic absence is already an internal war
Eleven Democrats did not show up for the vote and several have had to give explanations. Melanie Stansbury claimed a traffic jam; Jonathan Jackson, Marilyn Strickland and Laura Gillen repeated the traffic excuse. Eugene Vindman was at an event, Steven Horsford spoke about a personal emergency, and Nancy Pelosi spoke about a Veterans Day celebration. With those eleven votes, the resolution would have passed.
The internal anger was immediate. ‘We’re here to do a job, and the same way I clocked in when I worked in a restaurant, we have to clock in here,’ Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said. Sydney Kamlager-Dove was harsher: ‘There is no reason to have lost this vote because of attendance problems.’ From the other side, donald trump he simply settled scores: ‘The Democrats’ attempt to remove Secretary of War Pete Hegseth has failed miserably. All the Republicans, except Thomas Massie, a major loser, voted for Pete.’
Washington Logic
From within the system, Tuesday’s vote was neither an acquittal nor a conviction: it was a timing decision. He Republican Party he controls the House until January 3, 2027 and with that majority he has decided that his Secretary of Defense will not go through the wear and tear of a process opened in the middle of a war. The logic is the same as always Washington: impeachment is a political weapon rather than a legal one, and whoever controls the commission that processes it controls its destiny. The precedent illustrates this better than any speech. In 1974, referring the charges to the judiciary committee did not bury Nixon: the committee approved three articles in July, and the president resigned in August. In 2019 and 2021, the Democratic House passed theirs without a single Republican vote. The mechanism is never neutral. It depends on who manages it.
For Spain, the calendar matters more than the result. Hegseth will continue to head the Pentagon – renamed by this administration as the War Department – at least until January, and in that quarter the fine print of the American deployment in Rattan and Morón de la Fronterathe rotation of destroyers and the Spanish fit into the NATO spending objectives agreed in The Hague. The Spanish defense industry —Navantia, Indrathe military division of Airbus—maintains joint programs that need a stable interlocutor on the other side. Added to this is the energy front: the war with Iran that the Democrats use as a political argument has made crude oil more expensive and hits the bill they pay. Repsol, Iberdrola and Spanish homes. Madrid does not have a vote in the Capitol. He has interests.
The real risk is in January. The Democrats have won the majority in both chambers and the new Congress is formed on January 3, 2027. There the calculation changes: the House can approve the articles by a simple majority and the Senate, to convict and remove, needs 67 votes – two thirds -, a bar that requires a handful of Republicans willing to break with the White House and the speaker Mike Johnson (the speaker of the House and third in the presidential line of succession). Jeffries put it bluntly: ‘This is not the end. It’s just the beginning.’ Brittany Pettersen was more explicit: ‘Next year House Democrats will impeach Hegseth and neither Johnson nor Trump will be able to stop it.’ What we observe in the Capitol these days is a dress rehearsal.
Case File
- The case: Republican Thomas Massie presented eight articles of impeachment against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth. The House referred them to committee and closed the parliamentary process until January.
- Key facts: 211-204 in the referral vote; Massie, only Republican with the Democrats; seven Republicans and eleven Democrats absent; the Senate requires 67 votes to convict; The new Congress is formed on January 3, 2027.
- For Spain: three months of Hegseth at the head of the Pentagon in which the deployment of Rota and Morón, the spending committed to NATO and the Navantia, Indra and Airbus Defense programs are finalized.
