Judge Kuntz refuses to dismiss Trump’s lawsuit against the BBC for 10 billion and appreciates “actual malice”
IN 30 SECONDS
- What has happened? The federal judge Jeffrey Kuntzfrom the district of Floridahas denied the request of the BBC to shelve the company’s $10 billion defamation suit donald trumpseeing it plausible that the network acted with “real malice” in the editing of a documentary.
- Who is behind? A judge appointed by Trump, the British public broadcaster and the president of the United Stateswhich must be declared under oath before December 11.
- What impact does it have? It consolidates the Florida courts as a venue to sue European media and marks the terrain of transatlantic press freedom.
The federal judge Jeffrey Kuntz refuses to dismiss the Trump lawsuit against the BBC for 10,000 million and appreciates “real malice” in the editing of the documentary.
The 55 minutes that support Trump’s lawsuit against the BBC
The order has 40 pages and was signed this Tuesday in the federal district of Florida. The origin is a documentary of the BBC aired a week before the November 2024 elections, in which the network stitched together two comments from a January 6, 2021 rally to make it appear that donald trump supported the violence prior to the assault on the Capitol. The judge maintains that this union was not a technical cut, but the construction of something that was never said.
Between the two sentences there are almost 55 minutes of speech. «Editing is often necessary. However, given the temporal disparity between the two statements, the very distance points to the plausible inference that the BBC knew or should have known that the segment it was creating would not and could not be a truthful statement,” he writes. Kuntz. “It was not about trimming the edges, but about creating something different from what was said in the speech.”
The data is the distance.
From Social Truthhe president of the United States He spoke of “an enormous victory” against what he described as “a terrible abuser of the truth.” He later quoted a line from the car itself: «Here, the media created the news. The BBC admitted this by confirming that it had edited a video to make it appear that President Trump made a statement he never made. And he concluded: “We will continue fighting against all those who try to deceive the American people, and we will defeat them.”
The British network responded with contained surprise. “We were surprised by this decision, but we respect the authority of the Florida court in this matter,” a spokesperson said, adding: “We remain confident in our position and will continue to respond through the appropriate legal process.” The same source considered it “inappropriate” to go further while the procedure is ongoing.
Two sentences separated by 55 minutes of speech have been enough to bring Europe’s largest public radio and television station before the justice of an American state.
The car has two halves. Defamation claim continues; filed under Florida’s Deceptive Trade Practices Act (Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act) was dismissed. The lawsuit entered the federal district of Florida in December 2025 and the calendar is already tight: Trump must undergo a sworn deposition before December 11a period that can be extended. The judge also noted that the broadcast date, a week before the polls, was the one that could have “the most impact.”
“Actual malice”: the highest bar of American justice
The expression comes from the 1964 Sullivan case, the doctrine that protects the American press against public officials: to win a defamation lawsuit you must prove that the media published something false knowingly or with reckless disregard for the truth. It is the most demanding standard in the world on the matter, and most lawsuits die there. What is relevant now is that Kuntz considers that the threshold of “plausibility” has been surpassed, not that malice has been proven.
There is still no verdict.
For Spanish media that publish about American politics with an audience in the United States, the notice is operative: montage, ellipsis and file cutting cease to be a deontological discussion and become potential evidence in a Florida court. Any communication group with business in the American market—agencies, production companies, platforms—has a new reason to review its editing protocols. And the comparison with home illustrates the leap: in Spain honor lawsuits are resolved with the doctrine of neutral reporting of the Constitutional Court and with assessed compensation, not with proof of a subjective intention to harm.
Washington Logic
From within the system, this is not just a lawsuit: it is political communication with a judicial seal. trump He has been turning the courts into a stage for a decade, and Florida offers him two advantages that any American lawyer would instantly recognize. It is his state, with legal domicile in Mar-a-Lago, and his district accumulates judges appointed during his presidency. The coalition that supports this strategy does not need favorable rulings; the process is enough for him. Every appearance, every document of the discovery (the mandatory exchange of evidence phase) and each headline reminds the electorate that the republican party he wages a cultural battle against what he calls the establishment press.
Washington does not ask permission.
The most useful precedent is that of General Westmoreland against C.B.S. in 1984: another edited documentary, another defamation lawsuit that went to trial and ended without a ruling. The difference is that then the chain was American and the plaintiff was a retired military man; today the plaintiff is the president of the United States and the defendant, the public service of an ally. There is the novelty that affects Spain. The transatlantic relationship in information matters ceases to be soft diplomacy and enters into judicial files, and Florida establishes itself as a predictable forum to litigate against the presswith all that that implies to cover Washington from European newsrooms.
The key window is December 11. Before that date, the team trump must sit the president before the lawyers of the BBC for a sworn deposition, and a good part of the case depends on those hours: what he said, what he authorized and what he knew when the documentary was broadcast. If the deadline is extended, the calendar stretches well into 2027. The real question is not whether there was editing—that is admitted by the network—but whether an appeals court agrees that 55 minutes of distance supports the inference of deliberate deception. A jury will decide what the judge has only hinted at.
Case File
- The case: Trump sues the BBC over a documentary that, according to the court, joined two sentences separated by almost 55 minutes to suggest support for the violence of January 6.
- Key data: 10 billion dollars; 40-page auto; presidential deposition before December 11; The claim was dismissed under the Florida Deceptive Trade Practices Act.
- For Spain: The precedent reaches any European media with an audience in the US and reinforces Florida as a forum for lawsuits against the press.
